PDA

View Full Version : Future traded away for washed up has been, again.


Riggo
05.04.2010, 10:51 AM
Nothing has changed, the same "win now" mentality is still there even though it has never managed to produce any winning over the last 13? years and isn't likely to in 2010.

The_Doctor
05.04.2010, 11:29 AM
The Skins should still look at drafting a QB this year or next, but at least this should put you back in contention to hit the playoffs, even if only for a year. The NFC East is a tough division, and with a rookie QB you'd be lucky to get to the playoffs. I'd move Eagles right down to 4th after this trade, and unless Giants significantly improve this year, you guys might just make a wildcard spot behind the Cowboys.

sKiNsFaN
05.04.2010, 11:21 PM
Right there, now, Doc, you're talking my language see. :)

Harwich Hog
06.04.2010, 10:57 AM
I disagree Riggo - it's different when you trade for a QB, much more a QB of the quality of McNabb. It just doesn't happen.

my_friend_goo
06.04.2010, 02:41 PM
The Eagles still won with McNabb under centre this year as much as they did in the past few. Is he washed up yet? I just don't see it. He could potentially provide 3-4 years of starts for the Skins, allowing them to pick a future QB when they think they'll find him. Could be with Bradford going at #1, Shanahan and Allen just weren't convinced enough by any of the prospects to justify a #4 or #37 pick. Any of the guys available at those points could turn out to be a bust - McNabb has a proven history, just hope he brings it with him.

liverbirdpie
06.04.2010, 07:28 PM
the McNabb trade has less chance of being a bust than Clausen being taken at #4, or a Tebow at #37

He was the best QB in the division last year, and Shanahan can add a running game that the Eagles didnt offer last year to make him more dangerous. He has a composure and the experience that Campbell just didnt have last year, he paniced at times even when the line held up and as brave as he was I dont think anyone looked forward to having Campbell back at QB this season.

JD for breakfast
06.04.2010, 10:36 PM
McNabb is hardly washed up. 33 is no age for a QB in this league and although he may not be as capable of making plays with his legs these days he's still a big upgrade on Campbell